Finocchio`s in Garden City Beach

Very bad experience. Went for dinner tonight. Ordered a sweet tea and was told they didn't have any because they had no sugar. Only had Coke, Sprite, Ginger Ale, and water. Ordered a Coke the other two in our party had to also have Soft drinks that came out in what looked like a 4 oz glass. Ask for a larger glass after the 3rd refill. Was told they were out of bigger glasses. Ordered the all you can eat pasta and crab legs $32. Salad came out. Was just lettuce with two slices of tomatoes. When Crab legs came out the first round were OK, not much to brag on. Ask for another round of crab legs received one small cluster that were rubbery but tolerable. So got another round as we were waiting one in our party went and threw up the other stopped eating his and when my crab legs came they were still frozen. Even with making two out of three people sick and serving frozen crab legs were still charged $124. Will not eat there again and DEFINITELY NOT be recommending this place.

Delicious food and top notch service, under new ownership. New name is La Trattoria. Go and enjoy

While I like the food very much of the last three times there, the service has been less than impressive. Knowing it is a holiday and knowing the reservations you have why would you not think to add another serves. I would have to think long and hard whether or not I would try again

Terrible. Waitress did not give us a menu and then ask us what we wanted. If you want great Italian just go to Carabbas. Chicken Marsala had no Marsala wine . Sorry but not a fan.

Awesome foood, delightful waitress. Also to anyone that had a bad experience please try it again let Steve the owner know what happened he will fix what ever happened to you. There are new owners that just took over 6 months ago please try it again.

I ate there the other day and my server Jacob was spectacular so sweet and made sure our drinks stayed full. He was very well mannered and made sure we were thrilled with everything we ordered as we were. The food came out quick and all the employees made me feel like I was family if you ever are wanting good Italian food DONT hesitate go here!

Absolutely the worst experience I have ever had. Absolutely destroyed my anniversary dinner with my wife. They couldn't even make a drink right.

Food is great. Chicken parm is outstanding, best in myrtle beach. Cook and owner have can do attitude sometimes preparing foods not on menu.

Stopped here while on vacation. Place was amazing !! Bread was delicious! Huge portions on their pasta dishes! The owners are so sweet ! Both came out and talked to us. Made sure we had everything we needed plus some. EVERYTHING IS HOMEMADE. Would highly recommend!

The few bad reviews befuddle me! I dine here at least twice a month and have never had anything short of stellar service and incredible food. The owners are very involved and make sure eveything is to your liking. Give it a try - you will LOVE it.

Amazing, authentic Italian food. Every dish had its own unique sauce. Friendly, helpful staff

If you are used to the awesome Italian food offered in our major cities like NY , you will not be disappointed here. Great food and friendly people.

First-time customer and I really must say... the best italian food I've had. On par with any NYC joint. Service was impeccable. Food is truly 5 star. Chef/owner cooks order. Chicken masala and pasta fagoli were perfect. And 3 buck wines on Wednesday. In a real glass...by real I mean big!

Wonderful...just happened to drive by while my husband and I were looking for a place to eat out. Italian is always good. This was our first visit but it won't be our last. Great menu, had a hard time deciding, so we decided to come back and try another. Everything we had from start to finish was wonderful. This is our new local favorite!

We just had THE BEST dining experience!! This restaurant is truly a hidden gem and will now be our "go to" place. The food was probably the best Italian I have ever had, at reasonable prices, with superb service. The owners, who just took over the establishment 7 months ago, are fully involved in the business from cooking, to serving, and going to each and every table to greet their customers. We felt welcome, like part of their family, and it made our dining experience extra special. The food was out of this world good (and as an Italian family, we are a tough crowd) and was made from scratch, fresh, and authentic. We are absolutely stuffed!!!I cannot say better things about this restaurant and hope this review helps others make the choice to give it a chance like we did!!!

Absolutely delicious food and outstanding service. They do recommend reservations however they gladly accommodated our group of 6 since it was a little after their busiest dinner hour.

The veal was so tender, it melted in my mouth. The food is phenomenal and service immovable. Get your reservation now!!

We were unsure of this Italian restaurant in a strip mall. We were pleasantly surprised. The food was good, and the service was friendly. Would definitely return.

My favorite Italian restaurant anywhere in the country hands down! The staff makes you feel like family! Food is delicious, do not miss this gem ❤❤❤❤❤

I eat out 12 times a week... from coast to coast... the best italian food i have found..

I'm 40 years old and have NEVER experienced what I experienced tonight at this most amazing restaurant!! Not only was the food the most extraordinary I've ever eaten but the service we received (not only from the waitress but also from the owner/chef) was the absolute best service we've ever had!! That's not only coming from me, but also from the other 9 adults that were dining with me!! I am so happy to have found out about Finocchios!!Will most definitely be coming back every time I visit anywhere close to Myrtle Beach!!!!

Terrible overall experience and good luck getting your food or anyone to even take your order. I would never recommend this place to anyone

Wow!!! My 1st 5 star review. Absolutely fantastic. Coming back tomorrow. Scallops for appetizers and all dinners phenomenal. Jacob gave the best service and owner Steve came out to make sure we were happy. New tradition when come to Myrtle Beach.

I had the filet and prosciutto wrapped scallops. OMG! The Gorgonzola cheese sauce that comes with, meraviglioso! Wed nights are wine night. nice discounts. The homemade creamy Italian dressing, awesome. Then we had a butterscotch covered bread pudding. Fantastic. Its easy to pass up going south on bus17.

Terrible!! Worst Italian ever. Go to Olive Garden and get better for less. Out of 4 orders, 3 were wrong. Wrong pasta on 2, all sauces were runny and tastless, bread was late, cold, and day old. Salad was iceberg letuce and 2 thin slices of a small roma tomato. The most basic expectations for an italian restaraunt were not met , except for the for the decor, which was nice. Chef was very rude when we complained, but did not charge us as meal was unedible.

Best food and service I have ever had . The owner /chef is awwsome. Best dinning experience I have ever had the pleasure of dinning with.And the friendliest staff makes you feel like family unbelievable the service we got there

Service was great! Menu confusing due to incomplete statements, misspellings and poor presentation. Food was ok.

Great experience. Food was wonderful and our servers Chris and Jake were outstanding.

Great food and great chefs in the kitchen. If you haven't been call for a reservation and enjoy the best Italian food in myrtle beach!

Good dinner, quaint atmosphere. My wife and I liked the bread and Caesar salad. Scallops and risotto were wonderful. Friendly attentive service

I have been a customer since they opened their business after coming down from NY and have enjoyed all my meals there.

Finocchio's offers high quality Italian classics at a great value. Excellent casual dining experience. I had the chicken marsala.. delicious! My wife had the grouper special and it was prepared to perfection. Take a break from the typical and enjoy extraordinary!